The European Union as a Normative Power?
The Extraterritorial Reach of the EU’s Personal Data Protection Standards
Zusammenfassung
Geht die globale Verbreitung von EU-Normen mit einem Transfer der Rechtskultur und der Werte der EU einher oder existieren diese übernommenen Normen nur auf dem Papier? Das Buch kombiniert die Compliance-Theorie mit einem konstruktivistischen Ansatz, um eine eingehende Analyse des Prozesses und der Ergebnisse der Übertragung ausgewählter Artikel der Allgemeinen Datenschutzverordnung (DSGVO) in die drei Nicht-EU-Länder Norwegen, Serbien und Ukraine zu präsentieren. Auf der Grundlage der interpretierten Ergebnisse argumentiert die Autorin, warum die Kriterien des Brüssel-Effekts kein zufriedenstellendes Zeugnis für die normative Macht der EU liefern, und entwickelt einen neuen Ansatz zur Bewertung der globalen Verbreitung von Rechtsnormen.
Abstract
Is the global diffusion of EU norms accompanied by the transfer of EU legal culture and values, or have the legal norms simply become 'dead letters'? In this book, the author combines a theory of compliance and a constructivist approach to present an in-depth analysis of the process and outcomes of the transfer of selected articles of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in three non-EU countries, namely Norway, Serbia and Ukraine. On the basis of her results, she argues why the commonly applied criteria of the Brussels effect do not provide satisfactory testimony to the normative power of the EU, and she offers a new approach to assessing the global diffusion of legal norms.
Schlagworte
Brussels effect Allgemeine Datenschutz-Grundverordnung compliance Brussels-Effekt constructivism Compliance Datenschutz data protection EU European Union Europäische Union General Data Protection Regulation legal culture Konstruktivismus Normativmacht legal framework legal norms Norwegen Rechtskultur normative power Norway Rechtsnormen Serbia Rechtsrahmen transfer Serbien value transfer Transfer Ukraine Wertetransfer Übertragung von Rechtsnormen- 1–6 Introduction 1–6
- 113–118 Conclusion 113–118
- 119–142 References 119–142
- 143–246 Annexes 143–246
8 Treffer gefunden
- „... the domestic administrative apparatus corresponding with the newly adopted obligations while ...” „... 2012). Nevertheless, the author admitted that “the question of causation, whether the provisions found ...”
- „... , establishment of sufficient administrative capacities, the process of awareness-raising and monitoring ...” „... ‘Europeanisation’ also appears in the context of the acculturation and administrative institutions’ adaptation ...” „... political cycles tend to be longer, there is a lower risk that the change of administration would lead to ...”
- „... ’ status of the Act 2018 was the establishment of a well-functioning administrative apparatus to ensure ...” „... for other administrative/legal bodies. Finally, through supervision and case processing, Datatilsynet ...” „... administrative apparatus play a crucial role. These can be analysed based on the comparison of the adopted ...”
- „... (financial, administrative)in the domestic country YESThe low capacity of the Office has been repeatedly ...” „... , the Justice, State Administration and Local Self-Government Committee discussed the proposal. As nine ...” „... data subjects are expected to be secured by the appropriate institutional structure and administrative ...”
- „... (financial, administrative)in the domestic country YESOvercoming the low-capacity problem has been the main ...” „... relationships between administrations of existing and future EU countries.Until 2004, the Twinning projects were ...” „... could be appealed to the administrative courts of Ukraine (Draft Law on the DPA). The Commission should ...”
- „... YES NOthe unstable domestic political environment NO YES YESlow-capacity (financial, administrative)in ...” „... POSITIVE EFFECTS ON COMPLIANCE PRECONDITIONSfinancial, institutional, administrative andtechnological ...”
- „... of the Twenty First Century. A constructivist Approach’, The Public Administration and Social ...” „... , Nico (2006) ‘The Pluralism of Global Administrative Law’, The European Journal of International Law ...” „... a/advance-notification-of-an-administrative-fine--disqus-inc.pdfCase DT-20/02178 (2021): Datatilsynet. Decided: December 7, 2020. Published: January 13, 2021 ...”
- „... controller can charge a reasonable fee based on the administration costs. If the data subject submits the ...” „... reasonable fee taking into account the administrative costs of providing the information or communication ...” „... data subject, the controller may charge a reasonable fee based on administrative costs. Where the data ...”